P.B.P.F. - Benro C298n6 Tripod

P.B.P.F.
« Benro C298n6 Tripod »

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.
Dec 23, 2009, 6:27am

birdphotoph.proboards.com

Wild Birds of the Philippines

There are about 614 species of Philippine birds, and 194 of these are endemic to our islands. Over 10% of these species are globally threatened.

By imaging these magnificent winged creatures in their natural habitat and sharing the pictures and footages through the web, we hope that in our own little way we can help raise awareness for the protection of their habitat.

We wish that the children of our children will still be able to behold their beauty long after our generation is gone.

Forum Rules

Please read the Forum Rules before posting.

Bird Photo of the Week

Blue Rock-Thrush
(Monticola solitarius)

Exclusive Online Photo-Guide

PBPF hosts the searchable, most complete online Photo-Guide to the Birds of the Philippines. A work in progress, all photos were taken by PBPF photographers in-habitat. Species represented - 482 out of 614 as of November 7, 2009.

Space Available

If you’re interested in placing messages here, please contact the Administrator for more details.

W. B. C. P.

Visit the official website of the Wild Bird Club of the Philippines

Many PBPF members are also members of the WBCP, the World Bank Environmental Champion 2004 awardee.

Romy Ocon’s Galleries

PBPF Ranking

Welcome to the net's premier forum on Philippine Bird Photography. Please feel free to browse, share or discuss.
This Board contains personal reviews of birding equipment from members.

P.B.P.F. :: Forum Resources :: Equipment Reviews :: Benro C298n6 Tripod

Author

Topic: Benro C298n6 Tripod (Read 1,811 times)

Ding Carpio
Certified Birdnut - OCM

member is offline

[avatar]

Joined: Dec 2007
Gender: Male

Posts: 1,094
Location: Antipolo, Rizal, Philippines
Karma: 3

Benro C298n6 Tripod
« Thread Started on Jan 2, 2008, 8:41pm »

Posted a “first glance” in the Bird Photography Gear Forum about the Benro C298n6 when I just got this tripod. Now that I’ve taken it to a number of sorties (Candaba, Boso-boso, UP), I’d like to report my observations below.

As I already mentioned, I bought the Benro C298n6 from Aperture Trading (Banawe) for P13k cash (List price is P14.5k). This tripod belongs to the Benro HVC Flexpod series. Its specs and photos are in this Benro webpage: http://www.benro.cn/Product/1/pa5.html

Aside from its 4 sections, I have not verified the numbers (heights and weights). I can say, however, that it is much lighter than my previously considered Manfrotto 055MF4.

Overall first impression is that it is well made. One gets the feeling that it is a high quality product when handling it. The castings seem tough and sturdy. The legs feel supple.

On the field, I like the 4 sections because I can close it down to a short length and sling it diagonally across my back when hiking. It comes with a rather sturdy bag (which I wish was in camo). The bag has a small internal pocket that can store the accessories. Accessories include 3 steel spiked feet, a hex key (for tightening three screws in the head mounting plate), and a wrench tool for removing/tightening the main tripod head screw.

The center column can be locked with two knobs: one for locking the column’s vertical movement while the other is for rotating the column’s axis into a horizontal orientation. The center column can also be inverted so that the camera hangs from the tripod instead of sitting atop it. I think it’s cool to be able to do these although I have yet to find an appropriate situation (I’m sure I eventually will).

There’s a hook on the center column so that one may hang a heavy object to weigh down the tripod in case it’s too windy. Not sure how helpful this would be. I can imagine that, if the wind is strong enough to require the tripod to be weighed down, it would create too much vibration on the long birding lens anyway. Perhaps it would be more useful for counterbalancing really super-telephotos like the Sigmonster or any 600mm-or-greater lens.

I observed that the C298n6 is very stable. I think the general characteristic of carbon fiber is that it maintains strength while still acting as a good vibration-absorption material. I recall my old tennis days when my first-hand experience with carbon fiber is that it combines the feel of wood and the power of steel racquets. This same strength and vibration-free features can be observed on the tripod. Seems that Benro has also one-upped Gitzo by producing this tripod with 8 layers of carbon fiber (vs Gitzo’s 6) and Benro claims having the strongest, highest intensity carbon fiber in the market. On the manual is a photo of a man hanging on the tripod to demonstrate its strength. While this may be possible, I obviously preferred not doing this test.

The twist-type leg-locks took some getting used to for me since I had been using flip-locks before. One gets used to it. I can see the advantage on this locking design as it provides a more water-resistant, less-mud-prone leg design while keeping the whole unit robust. Benro’s leglock grips are also generous in size yet requires little twisting and little effort to lock in place. When slung on my back in a bag, I keep the lower legs unlocked for quicker set-up.

I found the spirit level very useful especially for us who usually shoot on uneven ground.

The spiked feet are also very useful. Once I replaced the rubber flatfeet with them, I kept the spikes on. I usually dig in the spikes into the mud with the lower legs extended even for a short length. I hesitate digging in with the lower legs completely recessed since that means mud may get into the leg joints. While Benro maintains its plastic bushings in the leglocks are water-resistant, no sense risking mucking it up.

Negatives? I observed three:

My Bogen 3421 head keeps getting locked too tightly. Yesterday, I had to spray WD40 to help me unlock it. But this could either be the head or me twisting it too much.
Wrong compass orientation. My north points south. It’s more of an irritation, really since I usually travel with a real magnetic compass. Also, I usually observe where the sun is so, most times, know roughly my orientation. I could bring it back to Aperture to change it but the trouble is not worth it.
The website mentions the legs have an Anti-Rotation feature. “Each leg section will not rotate even if they are unlocked”. Not really true. The top three sections do not rotate. The lowest section does. I can’t imagine how this untruth-in-advertising can be a showstopper, though.

Overall, I’m in love with the tripod. It’s the lightest I’ve seen for this category and relatively costs less. For now, it’s perfect for my use.

Here's a photo of it in action in Candaba courtesy of Manny Illana:
[image]

If you intend to get one, ask Aperture if they already carry the new Benro line: Travel Angel Tripod. The website’s specs show that this new line is lighter and can be folded smaller (more leg sections). You may want to compare this new line with the C298n6 if mobility is a prime factor for you.

Hope this little review helps!

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

I'd rather add life to my years than years to my life.

Ding Carpio

tina mallari
Moderator - OCM

member is offline

Joined: Dec 2007
Gender: Female

Posts: 1,793
Karma: 2

Re: Benro C298n6 Tripod
« Reply #1 on Jan 2, 2008, 11:10pm »

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this tripod Ding. A truly wonderful review that will be helpful to future tripod buyers, that includes moi.

After reading your review, it looks like I will be getting this one too but only after I look at that Travel Angel line of Benro - as per your suggestion also

Thanks again !!!

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

http://www.pbase.com/csmallari
http://www.csmallari.smugmug.com/

Ding Carpio
Certified Birdnut - OCM

member is offline

[avatar]

Joined: Dec 2007
Gender: Male

Posts: 1,094
Location: Antipolo, Rizal, Philippines
Karma: 3

Re: Benro C298n6 Tripod
« Reply #2 on Jan 3, 2008, 2:31am »

Glad my 2c is helpful.

The Travel Angel line looks promising. My only hesitation is that 1) It may be less sturdy given compromises in weight and 2) the many sections may be cumbersome during hurried set-ups and may introduce instability.

Of course, these are just wandering thoughts for now, until we get our hands on one.

Quote:

Thanks again !!!

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

I'd rather add life to my years than years to my life.

Ding Carpio

tina mallari
Moderator - OCM

member is offline

Joined: Dec 2007
Gender: Female

Posts: 1,793
Karma: 2

Re: Benro C298n6 Tripod
« Reply #3 on Jan 21, 2009, 6:29pm »

just an update so that others will not make a mistake ...

Not happy with the Benro tripod. The plastic thing inside the legs have a nasty habit of splitting into 2 pieces. The leg locking system does not seem to be holding up in some parts of my tripod and lastly, I like manfrotto's type of leg locking system - so much easier to set up and retract at the flip of the locking system.

I've decided to go back to manfrotto to lessen my headaches when it comes to my tripod